雅思终结者系列： GPT4到底比ChatGPT 强多少？

从雅思写作的水平来看，如果说ChatGPT是7~8分水平，那么GPT4就是9~10分水平。在作文批改和打分的准确性上GPT4也明显更胜一筹。

下面是对同一个题目的范文和同一篇学生作文的批改的对比：

GPT4:

给指定的雅思作文题目写一篇300个单词的范文：Itis important for people to take risks, both in their professionallives and their personal lives. Do you think the advantages of takingrisks outweigh the disadvantages?

题目：在职业生涯和个人生活中冒险很重要。你认为冒险的优点是否超过了它的缺点？

范文：

Incontemporary society, taking risks has become a prevalent topic ofdiscussion, as it plays a crucial role in both personal andprofessional lives. This essay will examine the advantages anddisadvantages of taking risks, ultimately arguing that the benefitsoutweigh the drawbacks.

Tobegin with, one of the primary advantages of taking risks is that itcan lead to personal growth and development. When individuals stepout of their comfort zones, they are more likely to gain newexperiences, learn new skills, and expand their horizons. This canprove invaluable not only in their careers but also in their personallives, as they acquire the ability to adapt to different situationsand face new challenges with increased confidence.

Furthermore,taking risks can be a catalyst for innovation and success. In theprofessional realm, it is often the risk-takers who drive progressand bring groundbreaking ideas to the table. For instance, numeroussuccessful entrepreneurs and business people,such as Elon Musk and Richard Branson, have achieved their status byembracing risk and exploring uncharted territories. As a result, theyhave not only transformed their respective industries but alsocreated numerous job opportunities and contributed to the globaleconomy.

However,it is essential to acknowledge the potential downsides of takingrisks. One significant disadvantage is the possibility of failure,which can lead to financial losses, emotional distress, and evendamaged relationships. In some cases, taking excessive risks canresult in catastrophic consequences, particularly when safetyprecautions are not adequately considered.

Nonetheless,when weighing the advantages against the disadvantages, it becomesclear that the benefits of taking risks generally surpass thepotential drawbacks. By embracing a calculated and well-thought-outapproach to risk-taking, individuals can minimize the chances offailure and maximize the potential for growth and success.

Inconclusion, while it is undeniable that taking risks involves adegree of uncertainty and potential for failure, the advantages ofpersonal growth, development, and innovation significantly outweighthe disadvantages. With a balanced and calculated approach torisk-taking, people can unlock their full potential and achieveremarkable success in both their personal and professional lives.

请扮演一名雅思考官，评分以下雅思作文，并指出其在任务响应、连贯性和衔接、词汇多样性以及语法多样性和准确性方面存在的问题；并提出相应的修改和改进意见，最后给出0~9分的成绩：“ Some people think thebest way to improve road transport safety is to make the vehicledrivers take the driving test each year. To what extent do you agreeor disagree? ”

Nowadays roads become busier and vehicle useglobally and wider, some people believe that the best way to improveroad safety is to test drivers every year. However, I believe thatthis is neither necessary nor practical, and there are other betterways to improve the safety of road transport.

Makingthe vehicle drivers take the driving test each yearIt does improveroad transport safety to some extent. For those young drivers, theymay be too confident that they are familiar with the traffic rules,so they can ignore the rules, but in fact, they do not have acomprehensive understanding of the traffic rules, or omit a lot,which leads to the safety of road transport is greatly reduced. Sotesting them every year can help them memorize the rules of theroad.  Secondly, this is especially important for elderlydrivers. As they get older, their reflexes become slower, as well astheir eyesight becomes weaker, and may become a danger to others onthe road. Through annual tests, Older drivers can improve theirproficiency of driving a car.

However,I believe that this way is not necessary and practical, and there aremore efficient and more suitable approaches to practice the driversand increase the safety of road transport. Most significantly, allthe people who take part in the test hope that they can pass thetest, so the annual test needs people to spend a lot of time toprepare. However, most of the drivers have very busy work, they don'thave extra time and enough energy to prepare the test fully.Therefore, by increasing tolls or fines, in this way drivers can obeytraffic rules more to some extent which can also increase the safetyof road safety. Moreover, giving rewards to drivers who have nottraffic accidents is a practicable option, which will ensure thatevery would follow these rules.

Overall,I think the most necessary thing is to enhance the drivers' awarenessof traffic regulations, which not only can save costs but also willmake a greatly improvement to the safety of road transport.

评分及反馈：

任务响应(Task Response): 6作文中明确表达了对问题的立场，即对每年进行驾驶考试的必要性和实用性表示质疑，并提出了其他替代方案。然而，作者在论证每年进行驾驶考试不必要和不切实际时，论据并不充分，也没有详细讨论其他方面的可能影响。

连贯性和衔接(Coherence and Cohesion): 6作文结构合理，段落之间有适当的衔接词。但某些句子之间的逻辑关系有些模糊，可能会让读者感到困惑。

词汇多样性(Lexical Resource): 6作文使用了一些多样化的词汇，但还有一些词汇可以替换，以增加多样性。例如，“increasethe safety of road safety” 可以改为“enhance road safety”。

语法多样性和准确性(Grammatical Range and Accuracy): 5作文中有些句子的语法表达不够准确，存在语法错误，如：“Nowadays roads become busier and vehicle useglobally and wider”。另外，部分句子缺乏语法多样性。

修改和改进意见：

任务响应方面，可以增加更多具体的论据和例子，以支持作者的观点。

在连贯性和衔接方面，应确保句子之间的逻辑关系更加明确，避免读者感到困惑。

在词汇多样性方面，可以适当替换一些重复使用的词汇，以增加词汇多样性。

语法多样性和准确性方面，需要检查并修改语法错误，并尝试使用更多不同类型的句子结构。

综合评分：6

作文整体上达到了一定的水平，但在任务响应、连贯性和衔接、词汇多样性和语法多样性和准确性方面仍有待提高。在修改和改进作文时，请参考以上建议。

题目：有些人认为，提高道路交通安全的最佳方法是让车辆驾驶员每年参加驾驶考试。你在多大程度上同意或不同意这种观点？

范文：

Roadtransport safety has become a pressing issue in recent years, as thenumber of vehicles on the roads has increased substantially. Somepeople believe that requiring drivers to take a driving test eachyear would significantly improve safety, while others argue that thisapproach may not be the most effective. In this essay, I will discussboth sides of the argument and provide my opinion on the matter.

Onthe one hand, annual driving tests could potentially improve roadsafety by ensuring that drivers maintain their driving skills and areaware of any changes in traffic rules. It is true that over time,some drivers may become complacent and develop bad habits, which canlead to accidents. Mandatory yearly tests could act as a reminder fordrivers to refresh their knowledge, stay up-to-date with trafficregulations, and remain vigilant on the roads. This would benefitboth the individual driver and the overall road safety situation.

Onthe other hand, critics argue that annual driving tests may not bethe most efficient way to improve road safety. Firstly, implementingyearly tests for all drivers would be logistically challenging andrequire significant resources. The time and financial costsassociated with administering such a system could be better allocatedto other initiatives, such as improving road infrastructure orinvesting in public transport. Additionally, research has shown thatmost accidents are caused by a minority of irresponsible drivers.Therefore, focusing on educating and enforcing stricter penalties onthese individuals may be a more targeted and effective approach.

Inmy opinion, while annual driving tests could potentially enhance roadsafety, they are not the most effective solution. A comprehensiveapproach should be taken to address the root causes of accidents,such as investing in better road infrastructure, promoting publictransportation, and implementing targeted education campaigns. Strictenforcement of traffic rules and harsher penalties for those whorepeatedly violate them could also deter dangerous driving behaviors.

Inconclusion, although mandatory yearly driving tests have some meritin promoting road safety, they are not the most efficient orpractical solution. A holistic approach, focusing on infrastructure,public transport, education, and enforcement, would be more effectivein achieving long-term road safety improvements.

Chatgpt:

Me:给指定的雅思作文题目写一篇300个单词的范文：Itis important for people to take risks, both in their professionallives and their personal lives.

Doyou think the advantages of taking risks outweigh the disadvantages?

ChatGPT:

Takingrisks is an essential part of life, whether it is in our professionalor personal lives. While some people may shy away from taking risksdue to the fear of failure, it is important to recognize that takingrisks can lead to significant benefits. In this essay, I will arguethat the advantages of taking risks outweigh the disadvantages.

Oneof the main advantages of taking risks is that it can lead topersonal growth and development. When we take risks, we are forced tostep outside of our comfort zones and confront new challenges. Thiscan help us to develop new skills and abilities, as well as increaseour confidence and self-esteem. For example, if someone takes a riskby starting their own business, they may learn valuable skills suchas leadership, problem-solving, and decision-making.

Anotheradvantage of taking risks is that it can lead to greateropportunities and rewards. When we take risks, we open ourselves upto new possibilities that we may not have otherwise considered. Thiscan lead to new job opportunities, promotions, or even financialrewards. For example, if someone takes a risk by investing in a newbusiness venture, they may reap significant financial rewards if theventure is successful.

However,it is important to acknowledge that taking risks does come with somedisadvantages. One of the main disadvantages is the possibility offailure. When we take risks, there is always a chance that things maynot work out as planned. This can lead to disappointment,frustration, and even financial loss. For example, if someone takes arisk by investing in a new business venture, they may lose theirinvestment if the venture fails.

Despitethe potential for failure, I believe that the advantages of takingrisks outweigh the disadvantages. By taking risks, we can grow anddevelop as individuals, as well as open ourselves up to newopportunities and rewards. While there is always a chance of failure,it is important to remember that failure is not the end of the road.Instead, it can be a valuable learning experience that can help us togrow and develop even further.

Inconclusion, taking risks is an important part of life that can leadto significant benefits. While there is always a chance of failure,the advantages of taking risks outweigh the disadvantages. By takingrisks, we can grow and develop as individuals, as well as openourselves up to new opportunities and rewards.

Me:请扮演一名雅思考官，评分以下雅思作文，并指出其在任务响应、连贯性和衔接、词汇多样性以及语法多样性和准确性方面存在的问题；并提出相应的修改和改进意见，最后给出0~9分的成绩：“ Somepeople think the best way to improve road transport safety is to makethe vehicle drivers take the driving test each year. To what extentdo you agree or disagree? ”

Nowadaysroads become busier and vehicle use globally and wider, some peoplebelieve that the best way to improve road safety is to test driversevery year. However, I believe that this is neither necessary norpractical, and there are other better ways to improve the safety ofroad transport.

Makingthe vehicle drivers take the driving test each yearIt does improveroad transport safety to some extent. For those young drivers, theymay be too confident that they are familiar with the traffic rules,so they can ignore the rules, but in fact, they do not have acomprehensive understanding of the traffic rules, or omit a lot,which leads to the safety of road transport is greatly reduced. Sotesting them every year can help them memorize the rules of theroad.  Secondly, this is especially important for elderlydrivers. As they get older, their reflexes become slower, as well astheir eyesight becomes weaker, and may become a danger to others onthe road. Through annual tests, Older drivers can improve theirproficiency of driving a car.

However,I believe that this way is not necessary and practical, and there aremore efficient and more suitable approaches to practice the driversand increase the safety of road transport. Most significantly, allthe people who take part in the test hope that they can pass thetest, so the annual test needs people to spend a lot of time toprepare. However, most of the drivers have very busy work, they don'thave extra time and enough energy to prepare the test fully.Therefore, by increasing tolls or fines, in this way drivers can obeytraffic rules more to some extent which can also increase the safetyof road safety. Moreover, giving rewards to drivers who have nottraffic accidents is a practicable option, which will ensure thatevery would follow these rules.

Overall,I think the most necessary thing is to enhance the drivers' awarenessof traffic regulations, which not only can save costs but also willmake a greatly improvement to the safety of road transport.

ChatGPT:

Dearwriter,

Thankyou for submitting your essay on the topic of road transport safety.I will now provide feedback on your essay based on the IELTSassessment criteria.

TaskResponse:

Youhave addressed the topic of the essay and presented your opinion onwhether annual driving tests are the best way to improve roadtransport safety. However, your essay lacks a clear thesis statementand a proper introduction. It would be better if you could state yourposition on the topic in the introduction and then support it withrelevant arguments in the body paragraphs.

Coherenceand Cohesion:

Youressay lacks coherence and cohesion. The ideas are not well-organized,and the paragraphs are not well-connected. You need to use morelinking words and phrases to connect your ideas and make your essaymore coherent. Additionally, you need to use proper paragraphing tomake your essay more readable.

LexicalResource:

Youressay has a limited range of vocabulary, and you have repeated somewords and phrases. You need to use a wider range of vocabulary toexpress your ideas more precisely and accurately. You can usesynonyms and antonyms to avoid repetition and make your essay moreinteresting.

GrammaticalRange and Accuracy:

Youressay has some grammatical errors, and the sentence structures aresimple and repetitive. You need to use a wider range of sentencestructures to make your essay more interesting and varied.Additionally, you need to proofread your essay to correct thegrammatical errors.

Overall,I would give your essay a band score of 5.0. To improve your essay,you need to work on your introduction, coherence and cohesion,vocabulary, and grammar. You can use more linking words and phrasesto connect your ideas, use a wider range of vocabulary to expressyour ideas more accurately, and use a wider range of sentencestructures to make your essay more interesting. Additionally, youneed to proofread your essay to correct the grammatical errors.

Bestregards,

IELTSexaminer

Me:给指定的雅思作文题目写一篇300个单词的范文：“Somepeople think the best way to improve road transport safety is to makethe vehicle drivers take the driving test each year. To what extentdo you agree or disagree? ”

ChatGPT:

Roadtransport safety is a critical issue that affects everyone who usesthe roads. Some people believe that the best way to improve roadtransport safety is to make vehicle drivers take the driving testeach year. While I agree that regular testing can improve road safetyto some extent, I believe that there are other more effective ways toimprove road transport safety.

Onthe one hand, regular driving tests can help to improve road safety.For example, young drivers who are overconfident may not have acomprehensive understanding of traffic rules, which can lead toaccidents. Regular testing can help them to memorize the rules of theroad and become more responsible drivers. Additionally, older driversmay experience a decline in their reflexes and eyesight, which canmake them a danger to others on the road. Regular testing can helpthem to maintain their driving skills and ensure that they are stillcapable of driving safely.

Onthe other hand, I believe that regular driving tests are not the mostpractical or efficient way to improve road transport safety. Firstly,it can be time-consuming and expensive for drivers to prepare for thetest each year. Many drivers have busy work schedules and may nothave the extra time or energy to prepare for the test fully.Secondly, regular testing may not be effective in identifying all thefactors that contribute to road accidents, such as poor roadconditions or inadequate infrastructure. Therefore, it is importantto consider other approaches to improve road transport safety.

Onealternative approach is to increase the penalties for trafficviolations. By increasing tolls or fines, drivers may be more likelyto obey traffic rules and drive more safely. Additionally, rewardingdrivers who have not been involved in any accidents can also be aneffective way to encourage safe driving habits. This approach can bemore practical and cost-effective than regular testing, as it doesnot require drivers to spend time and money preparing for a test.

Inconclusion, while regular driving tests can improve road transportsafety to some extent, I believe that there are other more effectiveways to improve road safety. Increasing penalties for trafficviolations and rewarding safe driving habits can be more practicaland cost-effective approaches. Therefore, I partially agree with thestatement that regular driving tests can improve road transportsafety, but I believe that there are other more effective ways toachieve this goal.